Pro Controller looks like the 360 Controller and they might make fun of how it is still for kids.
Pretty much, though of course this will be denied by the overzealous. If you swap the 4 buttons with the right analog, it is essentially a 360 controller with a few gimicks. Not like that's a bad thing gameplay wise, as it's one of the best controllers made in recent memory but it's a hate magnet from the Xbox fanboys.
That 4 button placement looks awkward. I'd have to reach across with my thumb towards the center and that might get unconfortable after a while. Once again, just like with the GameCube and Wii controllers, not good for fighters.
The problem is that, if they swap the 2nd analog with the 4 buttons, it'd just be a 360 controller.