23 replies to this topic

[Chaos]

The rules for this game are to choose your favorite anime out of the 2 you are given and give the next person a choice between 2 anime and they must choose their favorite out of the 2. It doesn't matter if you have seen them or not. If you haven't seen any of them, just vote for which one you think would be better. You can repeat choices, but don't constantly do the exact same 2 choices. Also, try to refrain from saying neither, where's the fun in that?

HAVE FUN!

First vote is
Sword Art Online v.s. Ao No Exorsist

Edited by Chaoskeleton, 17 December 2012 - 12:55 PM.

[Nollog]

SAO

Battle Programmer Shirase (BPS)
or
Steins;Gate

[Noonabites]

Stein's Gate. Otabe was eh at first but the anime is incredibly well made. That and I'm not too big on ecchi. (Though congrats on BPS having a story and decent characters)

Madoka Magica

or

Mawaru Penguindrum

Edited by Noonabites, 17 December 2012 - 10:25 AM.

[Chaos]

Madoka Magica


Darker Than Black

or

Death Note

[Goom]

Ha, I've seen half an episode of Death Note so i'm going with Death Note.

Also, you guys watch a lot of anime.



Sergeant Frog
OR
Angel Beats!

Edited by Goomba, 17 December 2012 - 10:35 AM.

[Noonabites]

EDIT:// Goom added options

Uhhhh... SRGT Frog I guess?? Hmph.

ORIGINAL:// Death Note. Also well made (despite the atrocity after ep. 26). Dark than BLACK was only okay.

Deadman Wonderland

or

Mirai Nikki

Adding this here because Goom didn't give an option to choose from.
And yes... We do watch a lot of anime.. but then again, I personally don't want much cable.. So I guess one makes up for the other?

Edited by Noonabites, 17 December 2012 - 10:39 AM.

[Goom]

Look again Buttercupcake ^

[Chaos]

Mirai Nikki. If Deadman Wonderland had a fuller story I might consider choosing it.


Toradora

or

Clannad Season 1

[Xiombarg]

Clannad simply because the characters were great. If it were season 2, it would fail.

Akira

or

Paranoia Agent

[CNR]

Never watched either of those but i choose paranoia agent because it sounds cooler

The world god only knows

or

The melancholy of haruhi suzamiya

Edited by Oblivion Comet, 17 December 2012 - 12:41 PM.

[Chaos]

The World God Only Knows. Haruhi Suzamiya went no where with the plot during season 1 and repeated the same episode 9 or so times because they couldn't think of anything else to do for the second season. Plus I love watching The World God Only Knows (Which might have a third season soon).


I'm going to be a little mean here,

Naruto

or

Naruto Shippuden

[Elric]

Neither.


Umineko no naku koro ni

or

Higurashi no naku koro ni

[Vegeta]

Neither.

Dragon Ball

or

Hunter x Hunter

[CNR]

Higurashi because of the amount of endless murders.

Kore wa zombie desuka

or

soul eater

Chao should not answer this one for obvious reasons xD.

Edited by Oblivion Comet, 17 December 2012 - 02:31 PM.

[Goom]

Soul eater


Full metal alchemist
Or
Full metal alchemist brotherhood

[Chaos]

FMA Brotherhood.


Da Capo

or

Campione!

[Auzzie Wingman]

Campione! Da Capo is just crap.

Infinite Stratos

or

Strike Witches

[Chaos]

Infinite Stratos. Strike Witches is blah from what I've heard.


Kore wa Zombie Desuka

or

Rosario + Vampire

[Xiombarg]

Korean Zombie because it makes fun of anime tropes. Rosario is just bad.

Mushishi

Or

Haibane Renmei

[Nollog]

Stein's Gate. Otabe was eh at first but the anime is incredibly well made. That and I'm not too big on ecchi. (Though congrats on BPS having a story and decent characters)

BPS is fricking awesome.
It's less ecchi than most anime nowadays though.

The World God Only Knows. Haruhi Suzamiya went no where with the plot during season 1 and repeated the same episode 9 or so times because they couldn't think of anything else to do for the second season. Plus I love watching The World God Only Knows (Which might have a third season soon).

<3

Mushishi

The art was fantabulous for its time.
Did you know it has a live action movie? (It's pretty bad)
Also loved the anthology-style episodes with the tiniest thread of linking storyline.
But I haven't seen Haibane Renmei... Still.

Saikano
or
Full Metal Panic!