15 replies to this topic

[grahamf]

Would TTYD be a game worthy of a remake a la WindWaker HD? It does have a significant item/stat system that could translate well to being always on the gamepad, plus could look very awesome in HD with touchups.

 

Thoughts?

[Atticus]

Never played the original, so it would be enough incentive for me to buy such a remake to try for the first time and in HD.

[grahamf]

I played through it a few years ago, but I never was able to beat Peach.

[Son Edo]

I don't know, is it?

[Raiden]

No. No more Paer Mario. Get Monolith or IS to make a sequelt o SNES Mario RPG. Or get Square again or Mistwalker.

[TheDoctor_13]

As much as I would love Paper Mario on the Wii U, the 3DS port does make more sense, more than Sunshine 3D anyways. It's paper, you can make it look more crisp, but it won't be omg its so much better. But I want it on Wii U more then 3ds. GAH.

[Xiombarg]

No. No more Paer Mario. Get Monolith or IS to make a sequelt o SNES Mario RPG. Or get Square again or Mistwalker.

Paper Mario 64 & Paper Mario TYD > Mario RPG

[Atticus]

Paper Mario 64 & Paper Mario TYD > Mario RPG

 

Thems fighting words! (Though to be fair, again I haven't played TYD).

[Raiden]

Paper Mario 64 & Paper Mario TYD > Mario RPG

Not a chance.

[Hank Hill]

Not a chance.

 

Judging from what I've played of Mario RPG and Paper Mario 64 (I own TYD but have yet to play it cause I have starting RPG anxiety) Paper Mario is a better evolution of Mario RPG. That being said, both are pretty fun games.

 

As for TYD HD...nah. I'd rather have a new Paper Mario on the Wii U rather than a HD remake. Though I would like TYD or Paper Mario 64 3D, even a two-pack. Portable Gamecube games in general would be fantastic.

[Raiden]

Judging from what I've played of Mario RPG and Paper Mario 64 (I own TYD but have yet to play it cause I have starting RPG anxiety) Paper Mario is a better evolution of Mario RPG. That being said, both are pretty fun games.

 

As for TYD HD...nah. I'd rather have a new Paper Mario on the Wii U rather than a HD remake. Though I would like TYD or Paper Mario 64 3D, even a two-pack. Portable Gamecube games in general would be fantastic.

Mario RPG forever own the Paper Mario series as much as I like it. Plus the Soundtrack was nothing less what you expected out of Square at the time. Mallow and Geno should be in Smash.

[NintendoReport]

[Son Edo]

I think PM is superior, it replaced RPG and it never got a sequel, that pretty much sums up the situation.

A lot of Paper Mario news and rumours lately too as well. Paper Mario 64 on Virtual Console, The thousand Year Door 3DS port, Paper Mario Wii U.

 

I'd like to see Super Paper Mario released on the Wii eshop to keep the trend going.

Edited by Son Edo, 11 May 2015 - 04:27 AM.

[TheUltimateWaddleDee]

Bowser's Inside Story >>>> Every other Mario RPG ever made.

Edited by TheUltimateWaddleDee, 11 May 2015 - 05:08 AM.

[Raiden]

I think PM is superior, it replaced RPG and it never got a sequel, that pretty much sums up the situation.

Never got a s sequel because Yamauchi gave Square the middle finger and him and Square became bitter enemies. Seriously. Paper Mario was Super Mario RPG2 as before the final name it was called Super Mario RPG 2 but finally changed to Mario Story in Japan abd Paper for the west.Yamauchi was a real prick lol,no one liked him esp his family. Square returned to Nintendo when Iwata was taking over. By the time things smoothed out Paper just had a run and both are great but I will always prefer RPG. Superstar games..eh first one is cool not that big on the rest.

Edited by Ryudo, 12 May 2015 - 10:13 AM.

[Son Edo]

Give it up while you're ahead, Ryudo. Haha