35 replies to this topic

[Alex Wolfers]

That is why I said not fanboys...
I think, as a fan of anything new, I wouldn't be able to review a game without a bias, but if someone who is content with a PS3 reviews it they won't be scared of picking out flaws or saying its not very good.
At the end of the day, someone who writes for IGN is a normal person, and their opinion might differ from yours. That doesn't make anyone wrong and the game instantly poor, it'll still be there for you to form an opinion.

I lost trust in IGN years ago.

[SoldMyWiiUAndLeftTheForums]

Is the review back up yet?

[Ravyu]

LOL To those who think IGN hates Nintendo. Their reviews of NSMBU and Nintendo Land are among the highest on Metacritic

[JaylisJayP]

For what it's worth, the average user score on metacritic right now is 8.7/10

[Mitchjg216]

If they arent biased than how did Goldeneye wii get a much lower score than GE reloeaded. It was the same game with a few different features.Please listen to reason GJ.

Goldeneye Wii got a higher score than Reloaded.

9.5


Googled it.

Hmm...that's interesting if true. Maybe they saw Gamespot's score and thought they were wrong. Heh.

Edited by Mitchjg216, 18 November 2012 - 08:35 AM.

[BobbyRiddle]

The review is live......6.3 with all the same shortcomings mentioned as the Gamespot review. Awful graphics check.....boring combat that us purposefully a chore in order to extend game life check.......no depth at all check.......great ideas but very poor execution check.

[Colinx]

I'm still getting it, it looks like a game I would enjoy.

[Stormage09]

ONM: 92
Eurogamer: 9
CVG: 8.4
Destructoid: 8
EDGE: 7
IGN: 6.5
GameInformer: 5
GameSpot: 4.5

[angelo07stang]

Pay no attention to the ign article it was reviewed bye greg miller he is a ps3 fanboy. Also some one else at ign did a early preview in late october and they called it the killer app on wii u so wtf happened between that time and now.

[Stormage09]

Im getting it anyways because of the ZombiU bundle, it also comes with a pro controller for a "cheap" price, its a good deal and i prefer zombiu to nintendoland anyways

[angelo07stang]

well my game has already shipped but im kind of dissapointed I hope it lives up to my expectations.

[Stormage09]

i think is the kind of game that you will love with all your soul or hate it will all your anger, there is no mid-term lol

[Wolfy]

I think I'm gonna buy this, it better not be a piece of crap, I've been looking forward to it since June.

[SoldMyWiiUAndLeftTheForums]

Such a wide spectrum on the reviews, very unusual indeed............

[MyNameIsMatt]

Think it's down to people's preferences on the combat.
To those calling Greg Miller a ps3 fanboy, he has stated in the comments he loves Nintendo...

[Gamejunkie]

Pay no attention to the ign article it was reviewed bye greg miller he is a ps3 fanboy. Also some one else at ign did a early preview in late october and they called it the killer app on wii u so wtf happened between that time and now.

To be honest that makes you sound pretty biased. It's well known that he is and has always been a big fan of Nintendo. At the end of the day he's just giving his own personal opinion based on what he thought of the game. So what if he's on the Playstation team. How does that make him biased or not right to review a Nintendo console exclusive game.

Edited by Gamejunkie, 18 November 2012 - 01:13 PM.