82 replies to this topic

[Crackkat]

hey all, i have already mentioned my concerns once or twice about this potential issue but was never properly answered. i think it's too important not to be discussed properly in a dedicated post. as far as i know, the wii u controller sliders aren't clickable like R3 and L3 for example. i see this as a serious issue that worries me when thinking about bringing good 3rd party games to the new console. for example, how can battlefield 3 be ported to wii u if there is no sprint button on the new controller? the touch screen cant make up for the sprint button, i'm sure no one wants to press the touch screen to sprint. so what are your solutions or ideas, i would really appreciate it if someone could put my worries to rest with a really good solution

(btw this is my first new topic and i have read the rules before posting and have also searched using the search box many times for a previous post that has already covered this and didnt find anything, sorry if i have somehow missed a previous post that already dealt with this)

[Andy]

The Classic Controller and Nunchuck's analog sticks aren't clickable. How was sprinting in shooters handled on them?

[AMAC]

There's plenty of other buttons that can be used for things like sprinting. The R button is used for sprinting in some PSP/3DS games, so I wouldn't be surprised if it gets used for sprinting on Wii U Games. There probably are some games where clickable circle pads would be good, but I don't see this as a major issue for the Wii U.

[Bill Cipher]

The Classic Controller and Nunchuck's analog sticks aren't clickable. How was sprinting in shooters handled on them?

If I'm correct, Sprinting was handled by pressing a button and running

[Andy]

The only games I can really think of that truly utilized clickable L3 and R3 buttons were Sly 2 and Sly 3. This is also the only game I can think of that made use of every button on the controller. L3 brought up mission markers. R3 brought up the binocucom. L1, L2, and R2 were used for equipment items. R1 was, guess what, a sprint button! Most games don't even use all four shoulder buttons, so I'm sure it would be easy to make one of them a sprint button. And lets take a look at the hypothetical situation that Sucker Punch goes third party and a Sly game comes to the Wii U. Mission Markers and the binocucom could easily be put on the touch screen. In conclusion, I don't really see not having clickable sliders as much of a problem, as all of the other normally unused buttons on the controller, and the touch screen, could quite easily make up for there absence without sacrificing any gameplay options.

Edited by Andy, 09 October 2011 - 10:51 AM.

[Auzzie Wingman]

Also, doesn't mean sprinting can't be re-assigned to a face button, shoulder button, and something else, like reloading, assigned to the touchscreen or as a motion gesture. Call of Duty and other FPS games on the Wii have easily converted to the Wii Remote + Nunchuk setup.

Give me a list of controls in CoD on a console, and I'll give you a list for a Wii U Tablet.

[Crackkat]

wow thanks all!! u have really put my worries to rest for the most part and i say the most part because i would still prefer sprinting with an R3 equivalent, but still, im happy resolved

[Brian6330]

To be honest, I don't find it really necessary. I prefer holding a button to run anyways

[Nintendo.fan]

definitely not. The buttons to the equipment will be subistituted by the touchscrenn so now there will be more buttons. The buttons without assignment have the same assignment that the normal game.

Edited by Nintendo.fan, 11 October 2011 - 09:09 AM.

[Auzzie Wingman]

Here's the way I see it:
Example - Call of Duty: Black Ops

Circle Stick 1: Forward/Back/Strafe
Circle Stick 2: Camera Control
L (That's the one at the very back): Aim
R: Shoot
ZL (On top): Primary Grenade
ZR: Secondary Grenade
Y: Reload
A: Action/Hold to run (Same as Wii Remote)
B: Pickup Weapon
X: Swap Weapon
D-Pad: Killstreaks/Equipment/Attachments
-: Scoreboard
+: Game Menu
Home: Wii U Menu
Swishing remote around like a madman: SLAAAAAAASH!

[MachineLaw]

Equipment could easily be accessed through the touchscreen via big ass icons, this would leave the control pad completely free with four extra buttons.

[giggity3000]

definitely not. The buttons to the equipment will be subistituted by the touchscrenn so now there will be more buttons. The buttons without assignment have the same assignment that the normal game.

if thats the run button how would you throw grenades or tactical grenades a Aim down the sight. Or choose equipment, or in some games pick killstreaks

[neverwinteru]

Here's the way I see it:
Example - Call of Duty: Black Ops

Circle Stick 1: Forward/Back/Strafe
Circle Stick 2: Camera Control
L (That's the one at the very back): Aim
R: Shoot
ZL (On top): Primary Grenade
ZR: Secondary Grenade
Y: Reload
A: Action/Hold to run (Same as Wii Remote)
B: Pickup Weapon
X: Swap Weapon
D-Pad: Killstreaks/Equipment/Attachments
-: Scoreboard
+: Game Menu
Home: Wii U Menu
Swishing remote around like a madman: SLAAAAAAASH!

this is the best and probably most likely option

[Joshua]

Remember that there is a massive 6-inch touchscreen on the controller that can be used as 'virtual buttons'.

[Auzzie Wingman]

That might be an issue though, if the developers aren't careful about it.

Remember, the Wii U will likely be able to play all Wii U games on the tablet screen alone. Now, I don't believe it will be a necessity (unlike the Wii where every game had to be Wii Remote usable), because Nintendo have said they want devs to feel flexible in what they do for the system.

That's why I haven't listed the touchscreen as any function for that CoD example. The screen will always display the same HUD values of that in other versions, minus controller specific tooltips.

While yes, the touchscreen can extend the button input versatility of a consoles makeup, developers need to understand that they can't just add everything to the touchscreen without thinking about it.

The only other thing I can think of that also works in that CoD example (in a way so that it doesn't compromise on HUD values, but so they don't have to do a motion gesture to knife) is to make that touchscreen a single function, in this case knifing. No matter where you'd touch that screen, it will knife, and so you can play the game separate from the TV, still have all functions and not have the HUD values disrupted

But even if you did this, you'd have to let go of the controller with a hand to touch the screen with your finger. That doesn't seem like the thing I would do, so the only other thing I can think of, without letting go, is to touch the screen with my runy, dribbly nose/chin. Not very practical, or hygienic, so motion gesture it probably will be.

I hope, for the sake of this system, that everyone doesn't go assuming that the touchscreen replaces all buttons. After all, simple is effective.

Edited by Auzzie Wingman, 09 January 2012 - 01:28 AM.

[Foot]

Two words, Circle Pads. The fact that they don't click like L3 or R3, or LS and RS is going to make it harder for developers to work with the controls. And before you start spazzing out about the touch screen, yes i know, BUT if you are into the game so much like a call of duty multiplayer, then you dont want to take your hands off of the primary controls to just to tap something on the touch screen.
Hopefully Nintendo takes that into consideration for e3 2012.

I actually had an idea to correct this while keeping the slide pads, where its more of a slide stick
 Wii U Slider Stick.bmp   752.12K   387 downloads
EDIT: Sorry about my amateur(I think thats how you spell it?) drawing, i made it in paint

Edited by Heyheyharold, 09 January 2012 - 05:49 PM.

[nintendo3DS]

I agree, I think they should add clickable analog sticks (L3 and R3) before the console is out.

[MoH]

I also agree - I'm used to clickable sticks and would also not want to move my hand placement to touch the screen.

[Rasvita]

Well you wouldn't have to take your hands off the controls to use the touch screen. Just be creative. Use a toe or a nose. If nothing else, just get someone else to lend you their hand.

I don't really see the non-clickableness of the slide pads to be a problem. Mostly because I've never had a system that had clickable analog sticks.

[Caius Casshern Sins]

Two words, Circle Pads. The fact that they don't click like L3 or R3, or LS and RS is going to make it harder for developers to work with the controls. And before you start spazzing out about the touch screen, yes i know, BUT if you are into the game so much like a call of duty multiplayer, then you dont want to take your hands off of the primary controls to just to tap something on the touch screen.
Hopefully Nintendo takes that into consideration for e3 2012.

I actually had an idea to correct this while keeping the slide pads, where its more of a slide stick
 Wii U Slider Stick.bmp   752.12K   387 downloads
EDIT: Sorry about my amateur(I think thats how you spell it?) drawing, i made it in paint

Why do you have the idea as me.

Edited by Caius, 09 January 2012 - 06:15 PM.